
From the company
Settle: Drawing the Line
The Story Behind the Music — Portrait Songs
There’s a difference between not wanting love and not wanting to settle for the wrong love.
I think that distinction gets lost sometimes, especially when someone else is convinced they know what’s best for you.
That’s really what “Settle” was about for me.
It came from a time in my life when I was figuring out who I was, enjoying being single, and refusing to let someone else make a decision about my future for me.
And, to be perfectly clear, I wasn’t exactly living like a saint.
The Version of Me Back Then
At that point in my life, I was dating a lot.
I was meeting different women, having short relationships, hooking up, and just experiencing life without looking for something serious or long-term.
That was the headspace I was in.
I wasn’t searching for someone to settle down with. I was trying to spend time figuring myself out, what I wanted, and where I was going.
It wasn’t that I had ruled out a serious relationship forever. If I met someone and it felt right, I was open to seeing where it could go.
But I wasn’t going to force that connection just because a relationship was available.
One particular experience brought all of that into focus.
I was seeing someone who wanted our relationship to become something more serious.
From my perspective, I had been clear from the beginning that I wasn’t looking for that. We could spend time together, enjoy each other’s company, and treat each other well, but I wasn’t promising a future together.
As time went on, though, it seemed like she started to believe that my feelings must be changing.
That because we had chemistry, because I could be affectionate, because I was treating her well, I must secretly want the same thing she did.
And I remember feeling frustrated by that assumption.
Being Kind Isn’t the Same as Making a Promise
This is one of the biggest things I wanted to express in the song.
I can care about somebody without wanting to build my entire life around them.
I can be romantic.
I can be thoughtful.
I can enjoy being close to somebody.
None of those things automatically means I’m ready to commit to a serious relationship.
To me, treating someone well is just how you should treat a person. It shouldn’t require a promise of forever.
And I felt like the fact that I was being kind was somehow being turned into evidence that I wanted something I had already said I didn’t want.
That was the frustration behind “Settle.”
I wasn’t saying that the other person was wrong for wanting a relationship. There’s nothing wrong with wanting something serious.
But there’s also nothing wrong with knowing you aren’t ready for that, or knowing that a particular relationship isn’t the one for you.
The difficult part is when two people want different things and one starts believing they can tell the other what they must really feel.
You Don’t Know What’s Going On in My Head
There’s a confrontational side to this song, and I meant for it to be there.
It was my way of saying: you don’t get to tell me who I am.
You don’t get to decide what I want.
You can have your opinion, but you can’t make that decision for me.
The verses push back against the idea that someone can look at me from the outside and understand everything happening in my head.
They also touch on how easy it is for people to repeat what everyone around them thinks is right.
There’s this expectation that eventually you’re supposed to settle down, choose somebody, and move into the next chapter of your life.
And maybe, from the outside, a particular relationship looks like it makes sense.
But other people don’t have to live inside that relationship.
I do.
What I find interesting looking back is that the song doesn’t pretend I had everything figured out.
I was still learning about myself. My life was moving, my thoughts were changing, and I didn’t always know exactly where I was headed.
But not knowing everything about my future didn’t mean I couldn’t recognize something that wasn’t right for me in the present.
In a strange way, that uncertainty is part of what made the boundary so important.
If I was still figuring myself out, why would I make a lifelong decision just to satisfy somebody else’s expectations?
What I Meant by Never Settling
The chorus is deliberately blunt:
“I will never settle.”
I wanted that statement to have some attitude.
At the time, it really did feel like a big middle finger to the pressure I was feeling.
But I wasn’t saying I would never settle down with anyone.
And I certainly wasn’t saying love wasn’t worth pursuing.
I was saying almost the opposite.
Love mattered too much to me to accept something I didn’t genuinely want.
When I thought about the person I might someday spend my life with, I had a sense of what I was looking for.
Maybe I couldn’t describe every detail, and maybe I still had a lot to learn, but I knew I didn’t want to talk myself into believing something was right just because somebody else believed it should be.
I wanted to recognize that connection for myself.
I wanted to choose it because it felt real, not because I was being pushed toward it.
And until then, I was willing to take my chances.
That’s the heart of the song for me.
Drawing a line isn’t always about rejecting another person.
Sometimes it’s about respecting your own feelings enough to be clear about what you can and cannot give.
No Villain in This Story
The song came from frustration, so naturally there’s some bite in it.
I wanted that energy.
I wanted the defiance.
I wanted the feeling of finally saying what I’d been trying to explain.
But looking back, I don’t think the story needs a villain.
Two people can enjoy each other’s company and still want different things.
One person might begin hoping for a future that the other person doesn’t see.
And even when you believe you’ve been upfront, feelings can make a situation more complicated than either person expected.
I can recognize that without changing what the song meant to me.
The person who inspired it wanted something meaningful.
I wanted the freedom to keep discovering what was meaningful to me.
Neither of those desires had to be wrong.
They just didn’t match.
What I was pushing back against wasn’t her desire for love.
It was the idea that I should want the same relationship simply because she wanted it, or because other people thought it made sense.
That distinction matters to me now just as much as it did when I wrote the song.
A Portrait of a Boundary
Every song on Portrait Songs captures something about a person, a relationship, or a moment that shaped who I was.
“Settle” captures a particular version of me: somebody who was enjoying the freedom of that period in his life, still figuring himself out, and maybe a little stubborn about protecting that freedom.
It’s not necessarily the most polished or settled version of myself, and that’s part of why it belongs on the album.
These songs aren’t supposed to pretend I had all the answers.
They’re portraits of the experiences that helped me ask the questions.
And this one was asking something important.
How much of your life are you willing to shape around what other people expect from you?
When it comes to love, how do you know the difference between compromise and giving up something essential?
I think there’s room for compromise in any real relationship.
But compromise and settling aren’t the same thing.
For me, settling meant choosing a future I didn’t believe in just because it was there in front of me.
And I wasn’t willing to do that.
So yes, “Settle” started as a pretty direct response to one particular situation.
It had anger in it, confidence, and more than a little attitude.
But underneath all that was something I still believe.
I wasn’t refusing to love somebody.
I was refusing to pretend.
And if I was ever going to choose someone to share my life with, I wanted that choice to be mine, and I wanted it to be real.
