Firetog & Co.
Support the Music
Circles cover artwork

From the company

Stupid Heart: Laughing at the Loop

I’ve always found it interesting how easily we convince ourselves that the next time will be different.

You meet somebody, things start going well, and suddenly you’re imagining all the possibilities. You tell yourself you’ve learned from previous experiences. You know what to look for, what to avoid, what mistakes you shouldn’t make again.

And then somehow, you find yourself right back where you started.

That’s essentially what “Stupid Heart” is about.

The funny thing is, I wasn’t particularly angry when I wrote it. I wasn’t sitting around feeling sorry for myself or trying to make some dramatic statement about heartbreak.

If anything, I was laughing at how ridiculous the whole thing had become.

I’d experienced two relationships that meant a great deal to me, both of which had already inspired other songs. Looking back at them, I started recognizing a pattern.

I kept allowing myself to get emotionally invested, convincing myself things might work out differently, and ultimately finding myself dealing with another complicated relationship.

At some point, you almost have to laugh.

Because how many times can you make the same mistake before you start wondering whether your heart has any idea what it’s doing?

Two Relationships, One Familiar Pattern

“Stupid Heart” was inspired by two different relationships.

One was the relationship that inspired “Portrait Song,” and the other was the relationship behind “212.”

Both experiences had already found their way into my songwriting, but I wanted to approach them differently this time.

Rather than writing another song about one particular person, I wanted to look at what those experiences had in common.

That’s where the structure came from.

Each relationship essentially had its own verse.

The opening verse begins with a memory of being on a date.

It was cold outside. I remember giving her my coat, holding her close, and kissing her underneath the night sky in a parking lot.

It’s a relatively simple memory, but those are often the moments that stay with you.

Nothing extraordinary has to happen for something to feel significant.

Sometimes it’s just being close to someone and allowing yourself to believe that something meaningful might be beginning.

I liked using that moment to open the song because it captured the innocence and excitement of a developing relationship.

That feeling of meeting somebody, letting your guard down, and imagining what might happen next.

And inevitably, there’s that little voice telling you that maybe this person could be the one.

Of course, that’s usually when my heart starts getting me into trouble.

My Stupid Heart

The chorus became a way of personifying my heart.

Almost as though it were a separate character trying to convince me to make another questionable decision.

There’s something amusing about that idea.

Your brain might recognize the warning signs. You might remember everything that happened the last time you found yourself in a similar situation.

But your heart doesn’t necessarily care.

It’s already imagining the future.

It’s already convincing you that this relationship could become something wonderful.

And you’re standing there thinking, here we go again.

I liked the idea of making my heart responsible for these decisions.

Not because I genuinely believed I had no control over my relationships, but because there’s something inherently funny about blaming an imaginary version of yourself for repeatedly making the same mistakes.

It’s almost like having an overly enthusiastic friend who keeps giving you terrible advice.

Every time you meet somebody new, that friend comes running back, telling you how amazing everything could be.

And somehow, despite everything you’ve experienced, you keep listening.

That’s the humor behind “Stupid Heart.”

It’s not necessarily about being bitter toward the people I dated.

It’s about recognizing my own tendency to jump into relationships with the best intentions and then wondering why things kept becoming so complicated.

Different People, Similar Mistakes

The second verse moves into the other relationship.

Although the circumstances were different, the larger idea remained the same.

Here I was again, emotionally invested in somebody, allowing myself to become attached, and eventually questioning how things had gotten so complicated.

I started thinking about how much of myself I tended to give when I entered a relationship.

I wanted things to work.

I wanted to be a good partner.

And when I cared about somebody, I was willing to put a tremendous amount of effort into making that relationship successful.

But looking back, I couldn’t help noticing that my approach wasn’t necessarily producing the results I’d hoped for.

Was I choosing the wrong people?

Was I approaching relationships the wrong way?

Was there something about my own expectations that kept creating these situations?

I didn’t necessarily have an answer.

And I don’t think “Stupid Heart” was written to provide one.

It was more about acknowledging the absurdity of repeatedly finding yourself in familiar circumstances.

Different person.

Different relationship.

Same heart.

Same mistakes.

And somehow, the same willingness to believe that things might turn out differently.

The Circles We Keep Making

One of the things I find interesting about “Stupid Heart” is how naturally it connects to the larger concept behind the album Circles.

The title track explores repetition on a much broader level.

The routines we follow, the patterns we create, and the ways our lives seem to move through familiar experiences.

“Stupid Heart” takes that same concept and applies it to relationships.

We meet someone.

We become attached.

We imagine a future.

Something changes.

The relationship ends.

And eventually, we find ourselves beginning that process all over again.

Every relationship is different. Every person brings something new into your life.

But sometimes the underlying patterns remain remarkably similar.

Even when we recognize that we’re repeating certain behaviors, recognizing a pattern doesn’t necessarily mean we’re going to stop following it.

Sometimes we’re perfectly aware of what we’re doing.

We just do it anyway.

Especially when emotions are involved.

That’s why I liked calling the heart stupid.

It’s not particularly logical.

It doesn’t always learn from previous experiences.

And it certainly doesn’t seem interested in following the advice your brain has been trying to give it.

But it keeps going.

And so do we.

Learning to Approach Things Differently

Those relationships eventually influenced how I approached dating for quite a while afterward.

I went through a long period of being single, exploring different relationships and experiences without necessarily allowing myself to become as emotionally invested as I had in the past.

In some ways, I think that was a reaction to everything I’d experienced.

I wasn’t particularly interested in putting all that effort into another relationship only to find myself repeating the same familiar story.

So I started approaching things differently.

That didn’t mean every experience was uncomplicated.

Far from it.

But I wasn’t necessarily entering those situations with the same expectations I had before.

Looking back, I can recognize how those earlier relationships influenced that period of my life.

I don’t think “Stupid Heart” was necessarily written as a declaration that I was changing my approach.

It was more of an acknowledgment that something had become obvious to me.

I kept allowing my heart to lead me into situations that eventually left me wondering why I’d followed it in the first place.

And sometimes recognizing that is enough to make you reconsider what you do next.

Looking Back at Stupid Heart

Compared with some of the other songs I’ve written, “Stupid Heart” is relatively straightforward.

There’s no elaborate fictional world.

No complicated mythology.

No grand philosophical mystery to solve.

It’s simply me looking back at two relationships and finding humor in the fact that I kept allowing myself to make similar mistakes.

And I think that simplicity is part of what makes the song work.

I didn’t want it to become another overly dramatic breakup song.

I’d already written plenty of songs exploring relationships, heartbreak, and the emotional weight of those experiences.

This time, I wanted to acknowledge that sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is recognize how ridiculous you’ve been and laugh about it.

Because there’s something funny about the way our emotions operate.

We can convince ourselves we’re being completely rational while making decisions that, from the outside, probably make very little sense.

And even when we know better, we don’t always do better.

That’s part of being human.

Looking back, I don’t regret having those relationships.

They were important experiences, and they influenced a tremendous amount of my songwriting.

Without them, songs like “Portrait Song,” “212,” and ultimately “Stupid Heart” might never have existed.

But I can still recognize the humor in how everything unfolded.

And I can still laugh at the version of myself who kept allowing his heart to convince him that this time, everything was going to be different.

Because no matter how much we think we’ve learned, there’s always the possibility that somebody new will come along, make us feel something unexpected, and suddenly all those lessons will seem a little less important.

And somewhere in the back of my mind, I can almost hear that familiar voice starting up again.

Hey, this could be something.

Here we go again.

My stupid heart.